I Did the Math on Connected Rowers. The $990 One Embarrassed Everybody.
Updated July 2026
Divide the sticker price by our 0 to 10 score and the connected rowing category gets uncomfortable fast. The Concept2 RowErg costs $990 and holds a 9.3, the highest score our research has ever produced. That works out to about $106 per score point. The Peloton Row costs $3,295 and scored 6.9, which is about $478 per point: more than four times the rate, for a machine that scored lower. And that is before the subscription line. Peloton now bills $49.99 a month and Hydrow $50, roughly $3,000 over five years, on top of the hardware. The Concept2 charges zero, forever, and its free ErgData app talks to Strava, Garmin, and more than 40 other apps. So if you are typing is a Concept2 worth it into a search bar, hunting for a rowing machine without subscription fees, or pricing out a Peloton Row alternative, this is your answer. We ranked all five by what a score point actually costs.
We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. It never affects our scores or picks. How we make money.
1 of 5
Concept2 RowErg
9.3
The math: $990 divided by a 9.3 score is about $106 per point, and there is no monthly fee to spoil it, ever. This is the machine every competitive gym and rowing program uses, units from the 1980s are still in service, and used ones hold $800 to $1,000 at resale, so even your exit is cheap. It splits into two pieces with no tools. The honest trade: the PM5 monitor is small and utilitarian, with no touchscreen and no on-screen classes. You bring the motivation. The machine brings everything else.
The math: $3,295 divided by 6.9 is about $478 per point on hardware alone. Add the mandatory $49.99 a month and five years runs roughly $6,294 all-in, which is about $912 per point, the worst rate in our research. What you get for it is real: Form Assist tracks your technique live and flags mistakes, and no rival teaches a beginner faster. What you also get: a 12 month warranty, a roughly $750 out-of-warranty screen replacement, and total lock-in to the Peloton ecosystem.
The math: $1,695 divided by 6.7 is about $253 per point, then the effectively mandatory $50 a month adds $3,000 over five years, pushing the all-in figure near $4,695, around $701 per point. The classes filmed on real waterways are genuinely motivating, the electromagnetic resistance is near silent, and at 102 pounds it suits apartments. But stop paying and you lose resistance control and coaching, so you are buying an ongoing service, not a standalone rowing machine. Know that going in.
The math: caught on sale around $1,799, a 7.0 score works out to roughly $257 per point, and the iFit membership at about $39 a month adds around $2,340 over five years. The 22 inch swivel screen and 10,000 plus class library are the biggest content deal here. The asterisks are loud: the machine cannot start a workout without an active subscription, and a NordicTrack software update once bricked thousands of consoles, settled in a class action. Buy it on sale, clear-eyed, or not at all.
The math: $2,199 divided by 7.6 is about $289 per point, which quietly makes it the best per-point buy among the subscription machines, helped by the cheapest membership of the bunch at $27 to $39 a month depending on how far ahead you pay. Instead of instructors you get gamified races and multiplayer challenges on a handcrafted cherry hardwood frame with quiet water resistance, and it stands upright to store. No coaching exists here at all, and the games live behind the subscription. For competitive self-starters who want furniture, not equipment, it is the defensible splurge.
By our math it is the single best value in home fitness. At $990 with a 9.3 score, you pay about $106 per score point and zero dollars per month, while the connected machines cost $253 to $478 per point plus $27 to $50 monthly. Add resale value around $800 to $1,000 and machines still running from the 1980s, and the question mostly answers itself.
What is the best rowing machine without subscription?
The Concept2 RowErg is the only rower in our research with no subscription at all. The ErgData app and online logbook are free, and it connects to Strava, Garmin, and more than 40 other apps. Every other machine here either requires a membership or loses core functions without one.
What is a good Peloton Row alternative?
It depends what you are paying Peloton for. If it is the classes, the Hydrow Wave delivers a similar instructor-led experience for roughly half the hardware price at $1,695. If it is results per dollar, the Concept2 RowErg scores higher, costs $990, and never bills you again.
